1. Android more trouble than it's worth
11/29/2012 2:52:10 PM
Android more trouble than it's worth
App Developer Magazine
Android more trouble than its worth

Android more trouble than it's worth

Richard Harris Richard Harris in Android Thursday, November 29, 2012

Google is still the champ in the smartphone world. A recent report by Gartner shows Android market share at over 72%. But what good does it do to put your product into a market like that if you can't monetize it right?

Users don't buy on Android as much

First of all, a little bit of data: until the end of 2011, 200m Android handsets had been activated. By June of this year, 900,000 Android phones were being activated each day; by September of this year, that figure grew to 1,300,000: Android is growing faster than iOS. Not only this: a little bit of math tells us that there are more Android phones than all iOS devices combined. So how come that IBM just told us that Apple's (AAPL) iOS led the Thanksgiving online shopping by 3.36 to 1 versus Android? Shouldn't it be the opposite?

Turns out, Android users are much less inclined to use their platform to do shopping online, or to pay for virtual goods like apps and music. The reasons, to me, are quite simple, and mainly derive from the fact that the high majority of Android devices still run on Android Gingerbread, a two year old OS, but most of-all, the extremely high majority is made up of low-end phones. This means two things:

  1. Most Android users are not inclined to spend on apps and music because the openness of the OS allows them to save money by getting content from other sources.
  2. Most Android users do not surf the web at all on their handsets (and therefore do not support Google's ads business), because it is difficult to do so on a low-powered phone with an old OS and a crappy interface.

This leaves Google with a huge customer-base, though, which does not serve its purposes.

Low Revenue

From the recent Oracle-Google dispute, we learnt that Google earned $500m from Android since its inception to the end of 2011. If we look atwhat Larry Page told analysts during an October 2011 conference call, we'll find out that in the same period the total revenues deriving from mobile were $2.5b. If we take out the $.5b earned thanks to Android, an astonishing 75%, or $2B, remains unjustified by Android revenues: that's what iOS brought in the same period: 4 times as much.

So all these Android devices and nobody making money on them? Actually there's somebody making a ton of money on Android, but you bet that's not Google. If we take a look at Samsung's (SSNLF.PK) latest financial reports, we can clearly see how the adoption of Android as their main mobile OS signed the beginning of an astonishing surge in revenues (and profits), until the recent record profit, achieved thanks to the Galaxy phones, which all run on Google's Android.

Samsung's success, therefore, relies heavily on Android, but it doesn't redistribute the profits to Google itself. Just a month ago, while Samsung profits were rocketing, Google gave that mid-day dismal earnings release, which will be long remembered.


iOS accounts for a huge part of the profits Google brings in from mobile. Problem is, Apple is making its best efforts to oust Google's presence completely from its platform. Maps are already gone, even though that led to a plethora of critiques, and there's no sign they're coming back soon. How much will it take for Apple to also find an alternative to Google search in Safari? Maybe years, but can really Google afford to take that risk?


Android has not revealed itself, until now, as a big enough source of profits for Google. At the same time, it caused the rage of Apple, which accused Google of blatantly copying iOS and which is now trying to oust Google's presence from iOS itself. (Something that could be Google's worst nightmare in a world where the user experience is heavily shifting towards mobile.)

Until Google finds a way to better monetize Android, or to wipe out the risk of being ousted from iOS, the stock remains a risky bet on the ability the company has to make profits from an environment which is revealing itself as more difficult to squeeze money from than the PC ecosystem did.

Read more: http://seekingalpha.com/article/1036221-android-ma...

Subscribe to App Developer Magazine

Become a subscriber of App Developer Magazine for just $5.99 a month and take advantage of all these perks.


  • - Exclusive content from leaders in the industry
  • - Q&A articles from industry leaders
  • - Tips and tricks from the most successful developers weekly
  • - Monthly issues, including all 90+ back-issues since 2012
  • - Event discounts and early-bird signups
  • - Gain insight from top achievers in the app store
  • - Learn what tools to use, what SDK's to use, and more

    Subscribe here